Killing the Buzz
“See with great clarity how much you presently treasure your suffering - how falsely valuable it has become to you…Man, in his present state, delights in sickness. Why? How can Mr. A see himself as a good man unless he can compare himself with the bad Mr. B?” - Vernon Howard
The jig is up. The Seoul correspondent of the Nishi Nihon Shimbun filed a report for their print edition this week and exposed the reason some South Koreans are desperate to cast Japan as the Evil Empire, despite efforts on both sides of the Sea of Japan to push the bilateral relationship in a positive direction. And there is no question the relationship is getting better every day. Here is our post about the events scheduled for Japan-South Korean Friendship Year 2005, one of the best ideas ever implemented for Japanese-Korean relations. Here, however, is a Korea Times article about some political opportunists who want to scuttle it.

Yet, despite the hysteria of amputated fingers and flaming arrows aimed at the police, we can wipe away the media froth and see that cooler heads are prevailing. Here is our previous post on the ongoing private-sector cooperation between the two countries. Following is a brief summary of some of the good news in Japanese-Korean relations that emerged since the Takeshima/Dokto and textbook controversies erupted.
Item: A South Korean company announced plans to begin regularly-scheduled sea cruises this July calling on Fukuoka City and Nagasaki in Kyushu, Cheju Island in South Korea, and other Korean and Chinese destinations. The week-long cruises will be based in Pyeongtaek, South Korea.
Item: The Beetle, a high-speed jetfoil service between Fukuoka, Japan, and Busan, South Korea, carried a record 350,000 passengers in 2004, a 13.9% year-on-year increase. Driving passenger totals upward was the Korea boom in Japan and the start of the high-speed KTX rail service in South Korea. Sharp rises were seen for Japanese women over the age of 60 and Korean women in their 20s.

Item: Interaction between the people of Fukutsu, Fukuoka Prefecture, and Kyongju, South Korea, is flourishing. The Fukutsu-Kyongju Culture and Friendship Exchange Association, a group of about 60 people, has been studying the Korean language and culture and conducting grassroots exchanges since 1998. The people in Fukutsu were due for a homestay and visit to Kyongju this year, but were concerned that recent tensions might scuttle the trip. They were relieved to learn that their counterparts in South Korea look forward to their visit, and their plans will go ahead as scheduled.
Item: The Lotte Giants baseball team from the Korean League held its spring training camp in Kitakyushu, Fukuoka Prefecture. The Giants and three other Korean professional teams played 10 games in the area in early March.
Item: The Kyushu Japan-South Korean Economic Exchange Council for promoting trade and investment by private sector companies in Kyushu and South Korea opened its doors in Fukuoka City. The council’s objective is to create a business network to strengthen ties between Japanese and Korean companies. The South Korean Consulate in Fukuoka City, the local South Korean Trade Center, and a Tokyo consulting company are working together on the project.
Item: Researchers from the Fisheries and Fishing Community Research Center of the Korea Maritime Institute visited Kashima, Saga Prefecture, to observe the Ariake Sea tidelands, known for their six-meter tide level differential, and talk about the Gatalympics. The Center is interested in the Gatalympics because they are studying ways to promote local economies using tourism in fishing villages. (Here is our previous post about the tidelands and the Gatalympics.)

Item: Warabi-za, a drama troupe based in Akita Prefecture, plans their debut performance of the musical Hyakuba in Arita-machi, Saga Prefecture next month. The selection of Arita, the production center of Arita and Imari ware, is apt because the musical tells the story of the wife of a Korean potter in Arita who became the progenitor of the modern Japanese ceramics industry. The protagonist was modeled on the wife of Lee Sampyung, brought from Korea to Arita about 400 years ago by Toyotomi Hideyoshi. The plot focuses on the cultural conflicts she faces in Japan, such as whether to hold a Korean or a Japanese funeral for her husband, and the differences of opinions she has with her Japanese-born son. The troupe chose this musical to celebrate the Friendship Year.
Item: After threatening to cut friendship ties due to the Takeshima/Dokto dispute , North Kyeongsang Province in South Korea invited Shimane Prefecture Governor Nobuyoshi Sumita to a May ceremony for the opening of the office of the Association of Northeast Asia Regional Governments. Shimane Prefecture is the jurisdiction in Japan with nominal authority over Takeshima. The same prefectural government upset the Koreans by declaring a Takeshima Day.
Despite the dire warnings of ruptured relations, the Friendship Year is still on track for success. Korean organizers scheduled more than 460 events for the Friendship Year in South Korea. A few, such a kabuki performance slated for Seoul, have been postponed for six months, but the bulk of the schedule is intact. In fact, only 10 of the events have been canceled.
One of the axed events was the screening of the animated feature, Hotaru no Haka (The Firefly’s Grave). The Japanese wanted to know the reasons for the cancellation, as Japanese animated films have a good reputation in South Korea, and the South Korean committee responsible for the year’s events approved the movie. The Korean PR company’s answer lifted the rock that exposed the wormy slugs to the sunlight.
Hotaru no Haka is the story of a 14-year-old orphan and his four-year-old sister in Kobe as they struggle to survive in the devastation of Japan at the end of World War II. Some Koreans objected to the film because it depicted Japanese suffering in the postwar period. They were incensed by the idea that Japanese could have been victims too.
“My suffering is worse than your suffering” is a consumptive, weevily game to play. Sixty years of Japanese behavior has demonstrated that the country learned its lessons from defeat. The war killed three million Japanese—500,000 civilians—and eliminated $26 billion of national wealth. It obliterated the Japanese empire for good and negated the influence of the military in society.
American air raids destroyed 25% of Japanese housing and 42% of urban industrial areas. An air raid on Tokyo in March 1945 using incendiaries killed 100,000 alone. The American air force designed the bombing pattern to obstruct people from seeking refuge in the river. Two atomic weapons continued to create victims decades after the bombs fell. (Check the link for one man’s story about his life after the bombing.) The Allied forces did everything but spread salt in the ground, as the Romans did at Carthage to prevent their enemies from rising again.
For some to face the fact that the Japanese paid their price and learned their lessons from the war would knock the struts from their emotional superstructure. It would deny them the delicious thrill of forever playing the victim and demonizing their oppressors. No more could they enjoy the surge of anger and passion as they relived events of their great-grandparents’ day. Gone would be the delight of wailing, gnashing of teeth, and rending the air with anguished cries of aikhu!
Recognizing that the enemy was a human being who suffered terribly for his sins deprives one of the pleasures of hatred. Why, that would spoil the fun.
It would kill the buzz.
It would deny them the delicious thrill of forever playing the victim and demonizing their oppressors. No more could they enjoy the surge of anger and passion as they relived events of their great-grandparents’ day. Gone would be the delight of wailing, gnashing of teeth, and rending the air with anguished cries of aikhu!
That is one of the more asinine and insulting things you have posted. My parents lived through WWII. Parents, not great-grandparents. I’ve personally interviewed hundreds of Koreans who personally experienced the loving embrace of Imperial Japan while I was in college. So this BULLSHIT you posted is no more than that, an insult to those that sufferred. Your trying to pawn this off on a younger generation of Koreans, ignoring those living who suffered through absolutely no fault of their own shows your utter lack of understanding. Your making light of their anguish is digusting at best. Why don’t you spend sometime and talk with some of the comfort women in Korea before posting such racist garbage.
You know, I was liking this blog. I hope you have enjoyed making light of the suffering caused. I came here for a better understanding of Japan. If this is it, I’m sorry I found it.
If you want to respond, do it by email, I won’t be back.
April 16th, 2005 at 12:58 amAmpontan,
You’re last few weeks of entries have been especially well written and thoughtful in my opinion. A pleasure to read. Thanks
April 16th, 2005 at 12:59 amp.s. I wonder if Plunge will/can keep his word?
yama-arashi
April 16th, 2005 at 1:04 amKyoto
Plunge is right, japan’s colonisation was incredibly brutal and I’ve heard stories from my granddad in prison camps in south asia and you have no right to make light of the suffering they experience. He was never able to walk again after the toture they inflicted. Japan having suffered does not exonerate them for having inflicted massive suffering.
April 16th, 2005 at 6:24 amAndrew,
Plunge and your comments prove the author’s point more than making yours.
April 16th, 2005 at 6:39 amRecognizing that the enemy was a human being who suffered terribly for his sins deprives one of the pleasures of hatred. Why, that would spoil the fun.
It would kill the buzz.
Why would you or anyone think “it would kill the buzz”. Does a murderer get any sympathy for being murdered himself/herself? I think not. Most would call it justice.
Overall your whole arguments pretty weak dude.
April 16th, 2005 at 10:04 amNo Yama you’re wrong. I love japan I lived there for years and years and I hold no ill will towards them.
April 16th, 2005 at 1:01 pmNo more could they enjoy the surge of anger and passion as they relived events of their great-grandparents’ day.
My grandfather, who is still alive, has every right to be angry and hate them. Trust me, he does not enjoy it.
JP, a very good posting, as is further evidenced by the fact that it chased away at least one hysterical ranter. A lot of people just love to keep the hate flowing. Witness Serbians slaughtering Craotians, and justifying it by the Croatian behavior in WWII.
For the record, JP is not minimizing the suffering of Koreans - he is simply protesting the exploitation of it to create more suffering in new generations.
April 16th, 2005 at 1:11 pmThat’s Ampontan to you, Mr. Fish! And thanks for getting the point.
- Amp
April 16th, 2005 at 2:00 pm“For some to face the fact that the Japanese paid their price and learned their lessons from the war …”
OK there isn’t really any widespread consensus that this has actually happened, not even within Japan, so this is pretty disingenous. You are right to criticize the immaturity of banning “hotaru no haka,” you are way off in pretending that there still aren’t things to take issue with.
April 16th, 2005 at 3:31 pmSorry about that. For all the flack, I may as well have your name right.
April 16th, 2005 at 6:04 pmAndrew
April 16th, 2005 at 11:35 pmkoreans were working as prison guards in japanese army in those days.
I agree with the point that ghoti and ampontan say about the younger people but I also agree with Gui and say that people like my grandfather have every right to be upset. Some of the victims are still alive.
April 17th, 2005 at 3:21 amAndrew,
I think that is more than fair. I also think even younger people should be upset. I know I am. (I still consider myself younger, probably not true!) And I hope even well after all the victims have left this world, we remain upset. The question is, it seems to me, the exploitation of those feelings by tyrants, demagogues and the rest. As well, the exploitation of those feelings while similar horrors are taking place now. That is not learning from history.
April 17th, 2005 at 4:40 amI love this site your last posting was wonderful,i really need a friend to be with thanks youall u can reach me afamj@justice.com
August 21st, 2005 at 6:57 amBeen angry will only worsen the the pains,lets learn to forgive and forget to make this world a betterb place for all of us without discimination.
August 21st, 2005 at 7:00 amafam