Pictures of Chairman Mao

At 814 pages, it may be a bit heavy for summertime reading—and may take the entire summer to get through—but Mao, the Unknown Story, by Jung Chang and Jon Halliday, seems to be a book that should be required reading for anyone interested in East Asia. Kevin Rafferty had this to say in his review for the Japan Times:

This is a nuclear weapon of a book. It devastates the reputation of Mao and most of his henchmen, and raises questions about the legitimacy of the ruling Communist Party…

Other writers have already exposed the monstrous nature of Mao’s rule, but none managed such a frontal, comprehensive attack…

Chang and Halliday remorselessly show Mao as a ruthless power-monger and plotter. Their almost unrelieved catalog of cruel terrors that occurred while his colleagues stood by cowardly and cowed, makes you wonder if whether anyone could really be so evil.

Among the points made (in addition to the estimate of 70 million Chinese killed):

  • The story behind the famous Long March is fictitious: Chiang Kai-Shek let Mao’s forces go.
  • Mao and his comrades never actually marched. They were carried on litters (The authors talked to people who were on the march.)
  • Mao never mounted serious efforts against the Japanese, preferring to spend his time eliminating his rivals.
  • In Yenan in 1941, Mao funded his operations by converting 30,000 acres of land to opium production. (Some years ago, a bearded, sandal-wearing professor of Chinese history told me that Mao banned opium for everyone but himself. He smoked one bowl a day because it “helped him to think”. The professor thought this was amusing.)
  • In power, Mao lived a life of utter luxury resembling that of an emperor. He had villas built throughout the country to his own specifications and used them once. Special fish were flown in live from 1,000 kilometers away so he could eat them with his special rice, water, and milk. (Sound like someone we know in Pyongyang?)
  • Joseph Mobuto Sese Seko (former dictator of Zaire), describes how Mao used foreign aid to foment world revolution. At its peak, foreign aid accounted for 6.92% of overall Chinese expenditures.

In addition to Mobuto, the authors also talked to Mao’s daughter and grandson, veterans of the Long March, two U.S. presidents, Henry Kissinger, an Oscar-winning actor, several other heads of state, and the woman who washed Mao’s underwear.

A 50-kilo Mao badge

Viewed from another perspective, this book may offer some clues for the reasons Japanese Prime Minister Koizumi doesn’t seem inclined to take seriously the Chinese complaints about his behavior and a few textbooks. The Chinese object to the content of Japanese history books, but none of this information will be found in any Chinese school text. The Chinese also complain about Yasukuni Shrine, yet as the book notes, “Today, Mao’s portrait and his corpse still dominate Tiananmen Square in the heart of the Chinese capital. The current Communist regime declares itself to be Mao’s heir and fiercely perpetuates the myth of Mao.”

11 Responses to “Pictures of Chairman Mao”

Andrew Said:

I take that with a grain of salt or two, but it is thought provoking and makes you wonder what’s the hell’s going on in China now with that whole bit about detained journalists.

Dan Said:

“Mao never mounted serious efforts against the Japanese, preferring to spend his time eliminating his rivals.”

Which gives an objective clue why Mao won and Chiang lost. Both realized that the war would be won or lost in the Pacific. But Mao was successful in creating the appearance of resistance while the KMT were not.

In much of modern warfare, appearence is reality.

Jaap Said:

In ‘Mao: a biography’ by Ross Terrill (1980) I read a wholly different story.
Who are these authors Jung Chang and Jon Halliday?

Synthstuff - music, photography and more... Said:

Moreon More On Mao…

I had written about a very interesting book here: “Mao more than ever” Now, thanks to Roger L. Simon, we find that the book is gaining traction. Here are two links worth looking at: The first one is from Japundit:…

lad Said:

This is in reference to comment #3. Jung Chang is the daughter of the old CCP elite. Read “Wild Swans” by Jung Chang. It the story of developments in Mainland China as witnessed through her and the women on her side of her family. It’s a long, but worthwhile read as it gives a good idea of how the culture changed in China from 1911 until the early 1950s. John Halliday is the Englishman who helped her publish this book. They are now married.

Bruce Said:

After all the hype and the dust settles, Ross Terrill’s book is the one scholar’s will still rely on.
Bet I could come up with a dozen women off the streets of Beijing who ‘washed Mao’s underwear’. How reliable are their sources?
I also could ring a casual acquaintance whose father knew Mao, his children, Zhu Rongji etc. And others who were part of the Cultural Revolution. This is not so hard as some seem to imagine. Maybe I should also write a book!
Yes, others have noticed that Jung Chang’s father worked in the Ministry of Propaganda, and she seems overanxious to exonerate her family while putting all the blame on the ‘Emperor’. Curious.

Bruce A. Said:

Crap, there’s already a Bruce posting here? OK…well…hum. Guess I can call upon my vast creative powers to come up with an alternative… how ’bout “Bruce A”? That different enough? I sure hope so…

Bruce Said:

But everyone here in Orstralia is called Bruce.
I don’t see the problem.
Don’t worry, I’m a single-issue man, and this is the last you will likely hear from me, thanks for the opportunity to be heard!

Gary Said:

Before some criticise the author or the book, would it be too revolutionary to suggest that they actually read it, or would that be too radical an approach? I have read it. What I have noticed is that none of the attacks on the book I have read are about the facts it contains - in fact many have been known in the Chinese world for ages, and particularly in Hong Kong where I live - but attempts to invalidate the writer. This is without doubt the most detailed research on Mao there has been. Unlike Terrill’s book, Jung Chang is coming in from criticism on two fronts. One says, it’s all lies; the other says “nothing new here, we already knew this.” It’s the old “Westerners (and their minions) don’t understand us”.

Japundit » Mao: the face of evil and the media who mask it Said:

[...] 8/10/2005
Mao: the face of evil and the media who mask it

At the end of June, we ran this post profiling the book, Mao, The Unknown Story, by Jung Chang and [...]

Book Info.net Said:

Mao: The Unknown Story by Jung Chang and Jon Halliday

Husband and wife author-team Jung Chang and Jon Halliday tackle the controversial topic of China’s legendary leader Mao Tse-tung in their latest scathing biography, Mao: The Unknown Story. Seeking to critically analyze Mao’s policies thro…

Leave a Reply

Design: Dao By Design | Powered by WordPress